Holyroodhouse Palace and Stirling
Castle are both in Scotland. They both have historic importance and
have been royal residences for centuries. However, the two present
quite different visitor experiences.
To begin with, Holyroodhouse is
located in Edinburgh whereas Stirling Castle is in the countryside
not all that far from Glasgow. Thus, a visit to Holyroodhouse is an
urban experience, something that you can do as part of a day in that
rather unique city. Stirling Castle requires a drive through some
pretty countryside from where the cruise ships dock in Greenock.
Although there are other things to see nearby, the castle is the
focus of the journey.
Stirling Castle sits majestically on
top of a stone crag. Perched on essentially vertical stone cliffs
dominates its surroundings. Holyroodhouse lies in a valley.
Overlooking it is the enormous rocky crag Arthur's Seat, part of an
extinct volcano.
Architecturally, most of the buildings
at Stirling date from the Renaissance. The palace building that we
see today at Holyroodhouse reflects the Baroque style of the time of
Charles II, although there are sections which are much older.
Both palaces were important in the
life of Mary Queen of Scots. She was crowned at Stirling and spent
her early life there before she went to France to marry the heir to
the French throne. She came to Holyroodhouse as a widow and some of
the most important events of the later part of her turbulent reign
occurred there including her two subsequent marriages as well as the
murder of her private secretary, which was carried out in her
presence.
After King James VI became King James
I of England as well, royal interest in both palaces declined
precipitously. Eventually, Queen Victoria revived Holyroodhouse as
a royal residence. Stirling Castle was allowed to become first a
prison and then a military base.
This history has an impact on what you
see at the two palaces. Holyroodhouse, as the official residence of
the monarch in Scotland, contains items of art and furniture from the
Queen's collection, many of which have been at Holyroodhouse for
centuries. At Stirling, most of its royal contents were dispersed
after the royals moved elsewhere. However, as a result of a 12
million pound restoration project, the Royal Palace has been returned
to its Renaissance look with high quality replicas of the art and
furniture.
As a functioning royal residence,
Holyroodhouse is not just a museum. People live there and it is used
for other things. Consequently, like Windsor Castle in England, it
has the feel of a living enterprise. Stirling Castle is essentially
a museum. However, to bring it to life, the Royal Palace has guides
who while dressed in period costume and assuming the identity of
members of the court of James IV tell the story of the Palace. It is
not only educational but entertaining.
Beyondships' article with photographs
on visiting Holyroodhouse Palace is posted at
http://www.beyondships2.com/cruise-destination-scotland-holyroodhouse.html
Our illustrated article on visiting Stirling Castle is at
http://www.beyondships2.com/cruise-destination---scotland---stirling-castle.html